Welcome to Tony's Pizza New York Style
Tony's Pizza New York Style, situated in St. Augustine, FL, is a beloved family-run establishment renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine. With its irresistible aroma wafting through the air, Tony’s offers a delectable range of dishes, including their celebrated cheese pizza and mouthwatering raviolis. Patrons rave about the inventive Greek pizza, featuring feta, black olives, and gyro meat, as well as their perfectly crafted calzones. The warm atmosphere, complemented by exceptional customer service, makes it a hidden gem for locals and visitors alike. For a memorable dining experience rich in flavor and tradition, look no further than Tony's Pizza New York Style.
Tony's Pizza New York Style: Reviews & Ratings
Our son told us about this place so we checked it out When you walk oh the smell tells you everything My wife had a cheese pizza and I had the raviolis Wow everything was so delicious Family business & Friendly staff Just go
This place is a classic for our family! We always order takeout on the first night of our stay. We like to GO EXTRA LARGE and EXTRA DISHES so we can have leftovers during the rest of our vacation. I tried the Boklava and they were delicious! They were fresh, made that day. The Greek Pizza is always great. The Extra Large goes the distance too. We have several slices to save for the rest of the week....The pizza is just as good cold, especially right after a hot day in the pool and beach. If you want something different than just the standard pizza then I suggest you get the GREEK PIZZA...Just make sure you like Feta, Black Olives, and Gyro Meat!!! I loved the STROMBOLI too !!! It was not overloaded with junk just great meat and cheese and not too much bread. The staff is very friendly. I order ahead of the rush time and I don't get in a big hurry to go the 3 miles...It will be hot when I get there for pickup!
My family and I have been coming here for the past 20 years. Tony’s Pizza is a hidden gem If you want real, authentic Italian food this is the place to try! Tony makes the best Italian food ever! I hope this place will forever stay open. We live about 2 hours away, but when we come down to Crescent Beach we always stop to bring home enough food for the week! The Calzones and the White Pizza specifically are the BEST EVER! But anything from Tony’s is always delicious and I recommend anything he makes! I can’t recommend this place enough to anyone looking for Italian food! You won’t be disappointed at all!
This was my absolute favorite meal on our vacation. I ordered the meatball sub. Our table also got spaghetti, a pizza, and the Tony's sub. Everything was excellent, and we all wanted more the next day. Lol. It was a little more expensive, but it was definitely worth it. I recommend 100%
I went into Tony’s with 5 in quarters I had in my car because my wallet was left at the beach. I asked if we can go in and get two slices of maybe just one for takeout if it wasn’t enough for my brother in law from out of town and they said they unfortunately don’t do slices. But then I believe the owner came up to us and asked us what we would like and I said I don’t think we have enough and he offered us a small cheese pizza anyway. I tipped all I had to show what I could to appreciate but the act of kindness shows the character of the staff of Tony’s. It could be horrid pizza and I would still eat here any time in the area because of how nice they were, but fortunately it tasted amazing and we were able to find a local gem down A1A south. Even if you aren’t a pizza fan they have other options and are great people inside and I’d advise to support people like this because communities need generous and wonderful people that we met today! Thank you Tony’s you earned a customer whenever I’m down in your area!
My family and I had spent an entire day traveling to reach our vacation destination and wanted a quick dinner. We tried this establishment and couldn't have been happier. We called in our pizza, the person on the phone was extremely nice and personable. My husband and father went to pick up the pizza were they were met with quick and pleasant service. The white pizza with chicken and onions added and the supreme pizza were both fantastic. We would definitely recommend this family oriented restaurant to anyone looking for an amazing pizza!
Got the Peperoni calizone, let me tell you something.. this's the best darned calizo i've ever had! Get you one today
This is the Best pizza in St. Augustine period. No frills or fancy signage just fantastic pizza. Definitely worth the short drive from downtown.
Location
-
6975 A1A S #2, St. Augustine, FL 32080, United States Hotline: +1 904-471-9027
Welcome to Tony's Pizza New York Style, a cherished gem located at 6975 A1A S #2, St. Augustine, FL 32080. This family-owned establishment is more than just a pizza place; it's a haven for anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine. From the moment you step inside, the tantalizing aroma greets you, hinting at the delicious offerings that await.
Tony's has won the hearts of many, as reflected in the rave reviews from satisfied customers. A standout dish is, of course, the classic cheese pizza, which one patron enthusiastically described as “delicious.” But the menu extends far beyond pizza. Indulge in the rich, flavorful ravioli and the unforgettable Greek pizza, a unique option topped with Feta cheese, black olives, and gyro meat for those looking for something beyond the ordinary.
Family loyalty shines through in the testimonials of long-time patrons. One enthusiastic customer has been visiting for over 20 years, calling it a "hidden gem." The calzones and white pizza are particularly recommended, emphasizing the consistent quality and taste that keeps families returning. The warmth of Tony’s is not just in the food but in the friendly staff who make each visit memorable. They embody generosity, like the owner who offered a complimentary small cheese pizza to a customer in need—an act of kindness that exemplifies the spirit of this wonderful establishment.
With an expansive menu that goes beyond traditional offerings, you can also try the delicious stromboli or meatball sub that fellow diners have described as “excellent.” The care Tony puts into every dish is evident, and past reviews demonstrate that even take-out orders are a delight, often enjoyed as leftovers during a vacation.
In sum, whether you are stopping by for a quick slice or indulging in a full meal, Tony's Pizza New York Style promises a dining experience that is not only about the food but about the community and the joy of enjoying delicious Italian cuisine. It’s a place where every bite tells a story and warms the heart. Don’t miss out on this corner of culinary delight when you’re in St. Augustine!